ClassicsToday.com
Artistic Quality 9/10 Sound Quality
“Christoph Eschenbach’s purposeful yet unforced interpretation ... exudes naturalness and balance. ... [His] fluid pacing is ever alive to the needs of the musical passage in question... . Eschenbach makes full use of his orchestra’s legendary tonal richness and instrumental color – qualities tailor-made for Tchaikovsky’s scoring... . The Philadelphia brass plays gloriously in this [final] movement, as throughout the work, and the rest of the orchestra ... displays its legendary virtuosity in spades. As a follow-up, Eschenbach offers engaging renditions of Tchaikovsky’s The Seasons (Nos. 1-6), making for an unusual and satisfying encore.”
April 2006
Gramophone
“... [W]hen ... Eschenbach launches into the Allegro vivace at a challengingly fast tempo the whole performance is transformed. ... From then on he sustains tension in the way one expects of a live performance, rounding it off with weightily emphatic repeated chords. No wonder that brings an ovation. ... [In The Seasons, Eschenbach’s] touch is magical, with rippling passagework that tickles the ear, and a natural feel for the flexible phrasing that the music calls out for. These are performances that characterize each movement brilliantly, full of fantasy and charm, with contrasts strongly established.”
May 2006
Philadelphia Inquirer
“…as an artistic statement, this Fifth wallows and weeps, it flies on the wings of euphoria.”
“…there is a lot of gorgeousness going on in the recording - a marvelous, pleasantly anachronistic ensemble sound…explosive (though not harsh) moments of arrival; and some phrases shaped so operatically you could almost put an imagined text to them.”
April 2, 2006
|